1up Vs eXilition

[Nadar]

zebra, so did VS (I can't remember them...?) just initiate through the whole round, or?

[lizardking]

Originally Posted by Kenny

The argument that was made earlier was that eXi played so hard they would have been too exhausted to play consecutive rounds when 1up was playing - as they didn't have the energy to beat an alliance as good as 1up twice in a row, who were by that point used to playing round in/round out.

1up were the better alliance because their contribution was consistent. eXi played hard for one round, then took the next off.

That said, I think their last two rounds were back to back victories, but by that point Sid had retired and the only real opposition were Conspiracy Theory, who sat out eXi's second round. The only alliance that came close to eXi in terms of skill that round was VS - and they allied eXi so that they could play with a smaller memberbase without being pounded on by the best alliance out there. The idea was to finish with highest average score, but after a couple of unannounced disappearances from key personnell the alliance gave up and eventually faded out of any kind of contention.

So yeah, an easy second victory for eXi - so no real credit there.

Heh, this' the same kenny who didn't know Sid while being his peon?
Pretty much says how much knowledge someone has about pa in general

Hmh, about playing 1435465 rounds streaks depends 100% of willness and spirit of the HQ and not of the whole. The base is always there, but if there's no hq the mercenaries find other employer ofc.

When comparing alliance A to B whatever the reason when other one beats the other 4 or so times the whole debate becomes pointless. When comparing howmuch A or B has tributed to the game is whole another story, and another thread. This topic was decided a long long timeago in a far far galaxy and the rebels won as they were restricted to grow AD-peniz.

End of ferrytale.

[furball]

And on that note I'm closing this thread.

The 1up v eXilition debate has gone on and on and we all know that there will never be an answer. Ex-1ups will almost always choose 1up. Ex-eXil players will always choose eXilition.

Every time this question comes up we see the same old arguments trotted out. Both sides make good points but there's nothing new to say. The more worrying thing is that, despite both alliances retiring several rounds ago, there's nothing new to talk about.