This is as much an original suggestion as the idea to breathe air is my intellectual property. I'm all for discussing new and interesting ideas, but the issue of lowering or raising alliance limits is neither new nor interesting nor particularly important. That's why I think making a new thread about it every round is rather pointless.
While I agree that the original thread contains some rather abysmal posts (especially once the QM debate starts), I have recently reread my share of the posts and most of them are fairly reasonable, while all of them are rational.
And yeah, sorry about the massive edit. I usually edit my posts about 5 times before I'm happy with them.