He said he has proof and asked for an official reply.
If you have nothing to hide why not stuff it into his face and show he is a liar?
Players dont sign up for an alliance with their Soul, they go for where they like it best.
On the otherhand, new alliances need to get new members from somewhere so its only logical that they are fed from the pool of this community and a few returners/joiners. Same happened to Eclipse, Mistu, LCH, Fang and every other alliance in this game. You would still be Eclipse if it would still exist, it disbanded you joined Rock nothing wrong with that
Going back to the initial Question, you want to let Sid run off with accusing you without any defence, or did he hit something you couldnt defend ?