Planetarion Forums

Planetarion Forums (https://pirate.planetarion.com/index.php)
-   Planetarion Discussions (https://pirate.planetarion.com/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   OMG , im CHEATING (https://pirate.planetarion.com/showthread.php?t=194581)

bintara 30 May 2007 15:41

OMG , im CHEATING
 
the reason why im posting this cause i just been accused (warned) that im cheating , and i want all of u guys to discuss bout it

here we goes :

[22:03] ->> You joined channel #MultiHunters
[22:03] ->> Channel Modes are: +tnT
[22:03] ->> Channel created on 11/7/2004 3:34:24 AM
[22:03] <B|nTaRa> oi
[22:03] <+Ace> hi
[22:03] <B|nTaRa> Warned:
[22:03] <B|nTaRa> You have been warned for potentially violating one of the Planetarion rules by Ace. The reason you were warned is: Abusive Language
[22:04] <B|nTaRa> Include your Case-id which is 291.
[22:04] <B|nTaRa> and include your user-id which is 1944.
[22:04] <+Ace> yes
[22:04] <B|nTaRa> wtf did i do ?
[22:04] <+Ace> what do you think you did ?
[22:05] <B|nTaRa> im asking u a question
[22:05] <B|nTaRa> answer a question with answer not a question
[22:05] <+Ace> and i asked you if you had any idea why you are here ?
[22:05] <B|nTaRa> ye
[22:05] <B|nTaRa> cause u sent me ingame mail
[22:05] <B|nTaRa> im asking .. for what
[22:05] <B|nTaRa> whats wrong ?
[22:06] <+Ace> asking ppl to send there ships away is against the rules
[22:06] <+Ace> and in many cases a valid reason for a closure
[22:07] <+Ace> so now you know why you are here
[22:07] <B|nTaRa> huh
[22:07] <B|nTaRa> so ,
[22:07] <B|nTaRa> i cant use diplomacy
[22:07] <B|nTaRa> i cant use my brain
[22:08] <B|nTaRa> what else i cant ?
[22:08] <+Ace> thats non of the above
[22:08] <B|nTaRa> what i did is DIPLOMACY
[22:08] <+Ace> nope it's asking someone to cheat
[22:08] <B|nTaRa> cheat ?
[22:08] <+Ace> to get your planet higher in the ranking
[22:09] <B|nTaRa> im tellin fact !
[22:09] <B|nTaRa> its up to him either to believe me or not
[22:09] <B|nTaRa> either he trust me or not
[22:09] <+Ace> dear sir,
[22:09] <+Ace> i know im alone attacking u , may i ask a favour from u ? could u please let me land ? please send away ur anti fr , with ur help , i canboost my score ALOT , thats all im asking from u cause i know deep inside ur heart , u r a kind man. i attack u because u can boost my score , atm im just top 700 , i really need this land , which can boost me to top 300 or less , please sir , help me .
[22:09] <+Ace> Regards,
[22:09] <+Ace> B|nTaRa
[22:09] <+Ace> thats asking the person to help you cheat
[22:10] <+Ace> and thats nothing else
[22:11] <B|nTaRa> that u call cheating ?
[22:11] * B|nTaRa slaps Soveh|aweh with a big red brick
[22:11] * B|nTaRa slaps Soveh|aweh with a rainbow trout
[22:12] <+Ace> I got more as you know
[22:12] <+Ace> u can take back ur roids , i just want the score and also the xp , thats all , thats why im asking ur help
[22:12] * Soveh|aweh was kicked by P ([email protected]) Reason ((Ace) be gone m8)
[22:13] * Soveh|aweh ([email protected]) has joined #MultiHunters
[22:13] <B|nTaRa> omg
[22:13] <B|nTaRa> what are u ?
[22:13] <B|nTaRa> u cant define diplomacy and cheating
[22:13] <+Ace> I am Ace
[22:13] <+Ace> a multihunter
[22:13] <B|nTaRa> u cant define bluffing and cheating
[22:13] <+Ace> I been around long enough to know thats not diplomacy
[22:14] * FieryDreamsofU ([email protected]) Quit ( Registered )
[22:14] * FieryDreamsofU ([email protected]) has joined #MultiHunters
[22:14] * P sets mode +v FieryDreamsofU for #MultiHunters
[22:14] <+Ace> nor is it bluffing
[22:14] <+Ace> if you add a calc to it too
[22:14] <B|nTaRa> so ?
[22:14] <+Ace> and i wanted you in here to explain it
[22:14] <+Ace> but it seems you want to play dumb
[22:15] <B|nTaRa> what im saying is .. IM NOT CHEATING and i DONT use ABUSIVE LANGUAGE !
[22:15] <+Ace> the abusive language part is done by the tool
[22:16] <+Ace> I wanted a explanation why your sending these mails
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> what kind of proof saying im cheating ?
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> did u get the whole mails ?
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> Dear B|nTaRa,
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> Please crash into me - I could use the salvage.
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> Regards,
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> Kileman
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> ------------------------------------
[22:16] <+Ace> yes i got the whole mail
[22:16] <B|nTaRa> i can call that cheating as well
[22:17] <+Ace> and i'm talking to you now not to him
[22:17] <B|nTaRa> he's asking to crash and he wanna use the salvage
[22:17] <B|nTaRa> why me alone ?
[22:17] <B|nTaRa> where is he ?
[22:17] <+Ace> dont change the subject
[22:17] <B|nTaRa> thats the same from my point of view
[22:17] <B|nTaRa> i dont change the subject
[22:17] <B|nTaRa> u using my mails saying that im cheating
[22:18] <+Ace> I asked you in here to explain it
[22:18] <+Ace> and your not
[22:18] <+Ace> and what i will discuss with him is up to me not you
[22:18] <B|nTaRa> explain what ?
[22:18] <B|nTaRa> abusive language ?
[22:18] <B|nTaRa> cheating ?
[22:19] <+Ace> i'll ask you again
[22:19] <B|nTaRa> im doing DIPLOMACY so i can land my attack
[22:19] <B|nTaRa> whats the problem there ?
[22:19] <+Ace> why are you sending mails to ppl to ask em to send ships away so you can land and score big and even offer the roids back
[22:19] <B|nTaRa> diplomacy + bluffing ?
[22:20] <+Ace> nope
[22:20] <+Ace> imo you where trying to arrange farming and get higher in ranking
[22:22] <+FieryDreamsofU> xp farming, to be precise
[22:22] <B|nTaRa> *sigh*
[22:22] <B|nTaRa> xp farming for attacking #1 uni ?
[22:22] <B|nTaRa> geeezz
[22:23] <+Ace> yes
[22:23] <B|nTaRa> why dont u warned the whole uni for attacking him
[22:23] <B|nTaRa> they all xp farming him
[22:23] <+Ace> and in return for it offering the roids back
[22:24] <+Ace> as the whole universe is not mailing him with what they want to set u
[22:24] <B|nTaRa> cause they dont use diplomacy
[22:24] <B|nTaRa> and i use it
[22:24] <B|nTaRa> whats the problem ?
[22:24] <B|nTaRa> some sent fake attacks , some attack and recalls and attack
[22:24] <+Ace> well since you clearly see this all as a big joke i will discuss it with the MH boss and we will see what we will do about this
[22:25] <B|nTaRa> go ahead
[22:25] <B|nTaRa> acccusing me cheating ,
[22:25] <B|nTaRa> ill take serious
[22:25] <B|nTaRa> ive been here since r3
[22:25] <B|nTaRa> and now u saying im cheating
[22:25] <B|nTaRa> geeezzz
[22:26] <+Ace> there is nothing geeezz about it
[22:26] <+Ace> thx for stopping by
[22:26] <+Ace> we will decide what will happen
[22:27] <B|nTaRa> what ?
[22:27] <B|nTaRa> after accusing me that then just leave like that ?
[22:27] <+Ace> nope i asked you a few times to explain it
[22:27] <+Ace> but you keep acting its a joke
[22:27] <+FieryDreamsofU> B|nTaRa: asking someone to let you land for roids/xp and then offering to let them hit you to get the roids back is a violation of rules 18.6.a and 18.1.a
[22:28] <+FieryDreamsofU> and I know that you are aware of this
[22:29] <B|nTaRa> *sigh*
[22:29] <B|nTaRa> [22:24] <+Ace> well since you clearly see this all as a big joke i will discuss it with the MH boss and we will see what we will do about this <<-- next time , talk to ur MH boss before accusing e as cheating !



*mails sent*

Dear B|nTaRa,

Please crash into me - I could use the salvage.

Regards,
Kileman

------------------------------------
dear sir,

i know im alone attacking u , may i ask a favour from u ? could u please let me land ? please send away ur anti fr , with ur help , i can boost my score ALOT , thats all im asking from u cause i know deep inside ur heart , u r a kind man. i attack u because u can boost my score , atm im just top 700 , i really need this land , which can boost me to top 300 or less , please sir , help me .

Regards,
B|nTaRa

============================================

Try 6:8:5 - your not getting roids here
------------------------------------
http://bcalc.thrud.co.uk/index.php?loadfile=main345615\

if u send away all ur anti FR , i can gain 3mil score which really help me a lot


------------------------------------
Dear B|nTaRa,

Please crash into me - I could use the salvage.

Regards,
Kileman

------------------------------------
dear sir,

i know im alone attacking u , may i ask a favour from u ? could u please let me land ? please send away ur anti fr , with ur help , i can boost my score ALOT , thats all im asking from u cause i know deep inside ur heart , u r a kind man. i attack u because u can boost my score , atm im just top 700 , i really need this land , which can boost me to top 300 or less , please sir , help me .

Regards,
B|nTaRa

==========================================

try 6 8 5 - he's easy
------------------------------------
u can take back ur roids , i just want the score and also the xp , thats all , thats why im asking ur help
------------------------------------
Try 6:8:5 - your not getting roids here
------------------------------------
http://bcalc.thrud.co.uk/index.php?loadfile=main345615\

if u send away all ur anti FR , i can gain 3mil score which really help me a lot


------------------------------------
Dear B|nTaRa,

Please crash into me - I could use the salvage.

Regards,
Kileman

------------------------------------
dear sir,

i know im alone attacking u , may i ask a favour from u ? could u please let me land ? please send away ur anti fr , with ur help , i can boost my score ALOT , thats all im asking from u cause i know deep inside ur heart , u r a kind man. i attack u because u can boost my score , atm im just top 700 , i really need this land , which can boost me to top 300 or less , please sir , help me .

Regards,
B|nTaRa

==================================

Warned:
You have been warned for potentially violating one of the Planetarion rules by Ace. The reason you were warned is: Abusive Language

Please contact a Multihunter (if possible the person who closed you, who is most familiar with the case) in #multihunters (or #support) on irc.netgamers.org or by using http://game.planetarion.com/support.pl

Include your Case-id which is 291.
and include your user-id which is 1944.

If you fail to contact a member of the MH team within a reasonable amount of time then you may be closed untill such a time as we can speak to you.

When replying via the support form, we'll try and answer you as quickly as possible.

This email is sent from an automated system and replys will not be read.
----------------------------------------------------------
If you need support, or have questions, please visit
http://game.planetarion.com/support.pl
and we will help you as soon as possible.

Planetarion is brought to you by Jolt Online Gaming Ltd. Reg. in England.
Copyright 1999-2007 Jolt Online Gaming Ltd. All rights reserved.
http://www.jolt.co.uk
----------------------------------------------------------

Allfather 30 May 2007 15:45

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
That there is just sad.
"Asking people to send their ships away is cheating" must be the dumbest thing ever to be said in planetarion.

SilverSmoke 30 May 2007 15:48

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
you've got to be kidding me

chemical 30 May 2007 15:51

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Agree.

but, begging is pathetic.

add100 30 May 2007 15:58

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
must be the MH team want to say every one is cheating :< what a sad life they must have

Nadar 30 May 2007 15:59

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
It wasn't cheating and it wasn't abusive language. It can however be annoying for the defender to be asked to send his ships away, but it's hardly an offense deserving a closure.

If it was cheating he must have been exploiting a bug, multied or cooperated with someone else, but none of these doesn't really apply here. Bintara should just say he won't do that again (it's a ridiculous thing to ask tbh) and MH should probably refine their rules a bit.

bintara 30 May 2007 16:04

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
This account has been closed by the game admins. If you wish to contact them, contact support here and ask for details regarding your case-id which is 291 and include your user-id which is 1944.
Keep in mind, if you know you have shared your login info with others, or that you have made or accessed more than 1 account, or violated the user-agreement in any other way, your account(s) will remain closed and there is no point is wasting our or your own

*sigh*

now i get closed

Quote:

------------------------------------
Dear B|nTaRa,

Please crash into me - I could use the salvage.

Regards,
Kileman

------------------------------------
why im the only one get closed ? why not him too ?

Archangelx 30 May 2007 16:06

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
that kileman guy must be a real hoser to report something as minor as that.
he ought to cowboy up and be a man, instead of tattling to his pa mommies.

sad state all around. im all for stopping cheating, but this is really pushing it.

man, lol, i still cant believe that kileman guy reported that, what a sad little man.

Shyne 30 May 2007 16:07

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
I think this closure is ridiculous. What will be used as evidence next, IRC banter?!

<Shyne> Send your ships away #1Planet so I can land
<#1Planet> Ok I will !!11111
<Ace> oh man, the above conversation is an agreed farm!

Mzyxptlk 30 May 2007 16:12

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Cry me a river tbh.

Allfather 30 May 2007 16:14

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
The farse is strong with this one!

SteInMetz 30 May 2007 16:17

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bintara
why im the only one get closed ? why not him too ?

Cause he used sarcasm, you might have heard of it.

Anyway, if you actually had treated the MH's nice and polite, you might have gotten away with it.. Deserved to be closed the way you acted :)

bintara 30 May 2007 16:20

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
im just thinking whats the reasons im being closed ? i get warned , so ? i get it and i argued bout it but i get closed ?

viC 30 May 2007 16:21

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

[22:07] <B|nTaRa> i cant use my brain
Nothing to argue with there...

Did anyone else feel like B|nTaRa's first mail could have been written by a Nigerian 419 scammer?

HRH_H_Crab 30 May 2007 16:29

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

I think this closure is ridiculous.
I think the closure is entirely justified on the basis that his "appeal" constitutes the ravings of a (possibly dangerous) madman that should not be let loose on the internet.

Whether he was actually cheating or not, is entirely immaterial.

Bane 30 May 2007 16:33

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Really he should be closed if he tried it again.

Shyne 30 May 2007 16:37

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
I can see that arranged farming is against the rules, but this wasn't agreed and didn't take place.

Lets nuke North Korea preemptively while we're at it MH !

`mac^ 30 May 2007 16:39

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
MH at their best.

iv had 2 warnings like this so far this round. Im still open.

This is rubbish.

bintara 30 May 2007 16:40

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
[23:16] <B|nTaRa> hmmm
[23:16] <B|nTaRa> whats the reason im being closed ?
[23:17] <+Ace> asking someone to let you land for roids/xp and then offering to let them hit you to get the roids back is a violation of rules 18.6.a and18.1.a
[23:17] <+Ace> as fiery told you before
[23:18] <+Ace> and if you dont agree with the closure you can ofc talk to fiery as she is my boss about the case
[23:29] <B|nTaRa> Ace, why dont u close my target too ?
[23:29] <B|nTaRa> he's doing the same thing as me
[23:30] <+Ace> like i told cr0 too I'm not discussing things about a planet with others than the owner of the planet
[23:30] <+FieryDreamsofU> and what was your target doing, B|nTaRa?
[23:31] * FieryDreamsofU is now known as Fiery
[23:31] <B|nTaRa> Dear B|nTaRa,
[23:31] <B|nTaRa> Please crash into me - I could use the salvage.
[23:31] <B|nTaRa> Regards,
[23:31] <B|nTaRa> Kileman
[23:31] <B|nTaRa> asking me to crash
[23:32] <B|nTaRa> thats cheating too rite ?
[23:32] <+Fiery> no
[23:33] <B|nTaRa> why ?
[23:34] <+Fiery> Would you like me to answer that in here or in #planetarion to save you the time of copy/pasting it?
[23:34] <B|nTaRa> u closed my account
[23:34] <B|nTaRa> close my target too to be fair
[23:35] <B|nTaRa> this is aint fair anymore

*sigh again*

Nadar 30 May 2007 16:42

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SteInMetz
Anyway, if you actually had treated the MH's nice and polite, you might have gotten away with it.. Deserved to be closed the way you acted :)

Many people deserve shit, but it doesn't make it right.

Bane 30 May 2007 16:42

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shyne
Lets nuke North Korea preemptively while we're at it MH !

Let's SK Shyne instead ;)

Even though the guy was quite rude to the MH team I think he was more shocked than genuinely trying to be an ass because he couldn't get his head around the rule. You gave him the warning but closing him now seems more out of spite, again as I said before, unless he tried it again or even took his behaviour further.

SilverSmoke 30 May 2007 16:42

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
It seems they're still talking like spastics on irc like if it's still 2001.

Benneh 30 May 2007 16:46

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Hope you stay closed.

bintara 30 May 2007 16:57

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
and again , here we goes.....

[23:38] <B|nTaRa> Fiery ?
[23:38] <+Fiery> I was replying in #pa
[23:39] <B|nTaRa> did u close my target too ?
[23:39] <+Fiery> nope
[23:40] <B|nTaRa> why ?
[23:40] <+Fiery> because he isn't asking you to farm him
[23:41] <B|nTaRa> errkk
[23:41] <B|nTaRa> he's asking me to crash on him
[23:41] <+Fiery> no
[23:41] <B|nTaRa> ??
[23:42] <B|nTaRa> what r u talkin about ?
[23:42] <+Fiery> You told him that you wanted to land on him for roids/xp
[23:42] <+Fiery> he's telling you to go ahead because he's going to obliterate your fleet
[23:42] <B|nTaRa> nope
[23:42] <B|nTaRa> he asking me to crash so he can use the salvage
[23:45] * AdmV0rl0n ([email protected]) has joined #MultiHunters
[23:45] * AdmV0rl0n ([email protected]) has left #MultiHunters
[23:48] <B|nTaRa> are u protecting my target ?
[23:49] <+Fiery> I don't particularly care who the target is. He declined your offer of farming
[23:50] <B|nTaRa> *sigh*
[23:50] <B|nTaRa> asking someone to let you land for roids/xp and then offering to let them hit you to get the roids back is a violation of rules 18.6.a and18.1.a
[23:50] <B|nTaRa> he asking for salvage

qebab 30 May 2007 16:59

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
You offered him to land on you for no costs. You offered him to farm you. This makes you a farm, and thus a cheater.

SteInMetz 30 May 2007 16:59

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Get over it.. See you next round!

furball 30 May 2007 17:02

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
bintara, you've been a complete retard here. Give up.

bintara 30 May 2007 17:13

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
furball , they CLOSED my account

Pat 30 May 2007 17:26

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
tbh the power is all in the hands of the #1 planet, in this case Kileman. And really its only cheating if he actually landed. And then if that happened i think you would have to call it blinding stupidity on Kileman's side, rather than cheating by Bintara. i think the MH's must have been bored one day, or perhaps enjoy a little virtual power of people :(

Assassin 30 May 2007 17:30

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
18.6. Miscellaneous cheating
(a) Attempts to encourage other planets to break the rules will be considered
a breach of this agreement

So he was asking kileman to send his fleet out, allowing him to farm off him. Which would of course have gotten kileman closed.

Think this ends this discusion as i just had it for around 30 mins in #planetarion. Kileman isnt closed becuase he simply to me told him he was just going to die if he landed on him. I do that to my attackers all the time. Thats a bluff. Although ofc you would od deffinatly died.

bintara 30 May 2007 17:38

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Assassin
18.6. Miscellaneous cheating
(a) Attempts to encourage other planets to break the rules will be considered
a breach of this agreement

So he was asking kileman to send his fleet out, allowing him to farm off him. Which would of course have gotten kileman closed.

Think this ends this discusion as i just had it for around 30 mins in #planetarion. Kileman isnt closed becuase he simply to me told him he was just going to die if he landed on him. I do that to my attackers all the time. Thats a bluff. Although ofc you would od deffinatly died.

well , why im still closed and Kileman is playing freely ?
close both to fair.

Wandows 30 May 2007 17:43

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
no no.... close the entire universe, that is alot more fair ofcourse. Because clearly when one planet is being closed for breaking (a/the) rule(s) we all should be closed! Fair is fair after all :salute:

Assassin 30 May 2007 17:45

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bintara
well , why im still closed and Kileman is playing freely ?
close both to fair.

Did you not just read my post? Your closed for that reason i said above. Kileman didnt break any rule at all so hes still open. Your now remaining closed becuase your still most likely denying you broke any rules. Your guilty, you remain closed. He hasnt broke a rule so he isnt closed. That not easy to understand?

cura 30 May 2007 17:46

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
B|nTaRa is a loser for begging people to let them land.
Ace is a loser for wasting his time with stuff like that (if you close him you can close half the pathetic universe).
Kileman is a loser for reporting.
I'm a loser for posting here.

countCount 30 May 2007 17:53

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Bintara, I think you could have saved your ass by saying the right things to the MH, before your account was closed.
Even though you feel that you are not cheating, they think you are, and they are the ones with the 'Close account'-button.

wakey 30 May 2007 18:17

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
I have to say that I agree with bintara that he hasn't actually cheated. He has seen he isn't going to land and has sent a cheeky mail in an attempt to bluff.

I'm sure most of us have after all pulled something simerlar where we message our targets or those attacking us to try and trick them. For example I have this round and rounds in the past asking people to send certain ships way so I can land simply to use the reverse mentality factor to reduce my losses by making them think i sent something different to what they would usually assume

Also he doesnt actually say "you can have the roids back for free". He says that killmark can come and get the roids back if he so wishes but doesn't say he wont put up a fight.

Chef! 30 May 2007 18:20

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
You are stupid for not being polite and sensible in first speaking to the MH's. For this you deserve closure.

Veedeejem! 30 May 2007 18:25

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chef!
You are stupid for not being polite and sensible in first speaking to the MH's. For this you deserve closure.

tbfh the way you speak to the MH's shouldn't affect your case.
There have been people that did far worse things but somehow managed to stay open.
This doesn't change the fact that bintara is bloody retarded for trying something like this, also killeman is retarded for reporting it, he should have just done nothing & let him crash to get the salvage.

I nominate this thread for post of the round btw :)

Mzyxptlk 30 May 2007 18:26

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
I think Kileman did the right thing. Maybe it'll stop people from acting retarded on the internet (but probably not).

wakey 30 May 2007 18:29

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chef!
You are stupid for not being polite and sensible in first speaking to the MH's. For this you deserve closure.

The thing is Chef if you get a warning or are closed which you think is wrong your going to be wound up. Its the people who are fully aware they have done something wrong who are polite and calm.

Last round for example Fiery Pm'd me accusing our scanner of being a support planet and cheating. When i informed our scanner of this he was understandably pissed as he had done nothing wrong and if it had been dealt with him directly would have vented his anger at the MH's like he did in our alliance channel. If he had would that really have justified him being closed, I think not
(For the record Fierys aligation was wrong as I was able to prove, the scans that were claimed to have been evidence of being a support planet were scans done for a galaxy he had later exiled from but which the MH had chosen to ignore before making the claim)

How you treat the MH's shouldn't come into it, if you cheat and your polite you shouldn't be let off (like ive seen happen to members of F-Crew before) and if the case is weak or false and your hostile you shouldnt be closed because you werent polite

bintara 30 May 2007 18:35

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
*sigh*

[01:23] <B|nTaRa> its start with a joke
[01:23] <B|nTaRa> Kilemen report it
[01:23] <B|nTaRa> u warned me
[01:23] <B|nTaRa> i asked why
[01:23] <B|nTaRa> u said im cheating
[01:23] <B|nTaRa> i argued
[01:23] <B|nTaRa> then u closed me
[01:24] <B|nTaRa> satisfied ?
[01:24] <B|nTaRa> im not a bloody cheator

and MH ignoring me

Bane 30 May 2007 18:41

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
The game doesn't win points with players who may simply quit the game now after such events. Players who get offended by silly mails should probably avoid the internet and stay in their homes, I think Kileman mainly did it for jokes.

The MH Team should have been the 'bigger people' and understood they'll get this kind of talk from people they say are cheating even though the accused may not understand/believe it. Closing this account serves no purpose, you may say a 'cheater' is gone but he merely asked and there is no compulsion for Kileman to agree, all bintara is guilty of is just being a muppet. Yes some people are immature but it happens, if the MH team can't handle it then they should quit.

Assassin 30 May 2007 18:51

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Veedeejem!
tbfh the way you speak to the MH's shouldn't affect your case.
There have been people that did far worse things but somehow managed to stay open.
This doesn't change the fact that bintara is bloody retarded for trying something like this, also killeman is retarded for reporting it, he should have just done nothing & let him crash to get the salvage.

I nominate this thread for post of the round btw :)

Fact is he broke a rule. For example how do we know he wasnt trying to get kile closed? Thats why kile most likely reported it. Becuase we then get those idiots who go 'oh look hes farming' etc and try to report him.

I produced a part of the eula which covers this. He did it. I wouldnt of closed him, ill admit that openly. I would of warned him and maybe recalled the fleet and sent him on his way. But i guess the other reasons as to why he was closed was the way he spoke to a MH (ie basicaly still to this point claiming he wasnt cheating... i also had a 40 min rant in #pa with him so i know how persistant he is ) Also coming onto these forums producing logs and the mails. Which to me shows he blatently offered to roid him for XP, then offered he could retal him back for the roids. Its hillarious this guy can argue the case he hasnt done anything wrong. If it was meant to be a joke, it just wasnt funny

But fact is wakey that isnt a bluff. A bluff would be mailing my attacker telling him 'oh ive built ships for you to land on' thats a bluff, asking somone to send his fleet out is not a bluff. Its a request, which if kile had done so, would of got kile closed. And if kile had let him land, he would of most likely been reported anyway as farming for salvage to win the round. So he did the right thing in reporting it.

Wandows 30 May 2007 18:53

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Assassin
For example how do we know he wasnt trying to get kile closed? Thats why kile most likely reported it.

This line alone describes perfectly what is wrong with the current EULA.

bintara 30 May 2007 19:29

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

But fact is wakey that isnt a bluff. A bluff would be mailing my attacker telling him 'oh ive built ships for you to land on' thats a bluff, asking somone to send his fleet out is not a bluff. Its a request, which if kile had done so, would of got kile closed. And if kile had let him land, he would of most likely been reported anyway as farming for salvage to win the round. So he did the right thing in reporting it.
"pls crash at me" by your point is asking for farming

kile did the same thing as me , why im the only being closed ?

Talin 30 May 2007 20:00

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Hi.

You have just made me dig out an account I never actually used (and it's not a gimmick, before you make that assumption) to reply in this thread.

And my reply is: WHAT?

Seriously, do the following steps:

Erase this joke novel of an EULA Planetarion has today, and write it all over again, presumably using common sense and not attemting to make an ultimately fair game if that means making it completely ridiculous at the same time.

Appoint MH with the above mentioned common sense.

This example should be recorded in the history as something where humanity went very, very wrong.

Assassin 30 May 2007 20:01

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bintara
"pls crash at me" by your point is asking for farming

kile did the same thing as me , why im the only being closed ?


Ill ask again. Do you not read either the irc convos me and yourself have or the posts i make? I undertstand your probably anoyed you have been closed. But just been ignorent is anoying me now.

So ill put these into simple steps for you.

1) Kile wasnt closed becuase he did infact send you a mail also asking you to land for salvage. However, its blatently obvious hes doing that in sarcasm by telling you there is no point as your just going to die.

2) He reported you. Meaning he obviously doesnt want people thinking he was going to have you land on him for salvage. So he stopped you.

Now. If you cant understand that, then tbh im starting to wonder if your whole mission here wasnt infact to try and get kile closed. You sent those mails claiming to be a 'bluff' it backfired on you. And now you have been punished your still trying to drag him down with you. So this can be 2 things 1) Your attention seaking. Due to thefact you have been closed and you think its been done wrongly. or 2) Your whole aim was to get him closed one way or another.

wakey 30 May 2007 20:06

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Assassin
But fact is wakey that isnt a bluff. A bluff would be mailing my attacker telling him 'oh ive built ships for you to land on' thats a bluff, asking somone to send his fleet out is not a bluff. Its a request, which if kile had done so, would of got kile closed. And if kile had let him land, he would of most likely been reported anyway as farming for salvage to win the round. So he did the right thing in reporting it.

Since when have bluffs been one way. You can bluff as an attacker also by making the defender think you have attacked with other ships than you actually have. I'm not saying that necessarily what's happened here but you can bluff as an attacker, hey ive done it numerous times over the rounds. You make your fleet look like something else, you reinforce that by asking them to send away the ships that target the 'fake fleet' and then hope they run the ships that target the real fleet while leaving the ships you asked them to run.

And what about the people who send out fake bcalcs to get you to run or crash fleets. Is that encouraging you to cheat also.

And finally the simple factor is no matter if he was attempting to cheat, was joking or was bluffing the MH's were letting him off yet changed their mind soley on attitude. Attitude shouldn't be a factor, just because you act nice shouldn't get guilty people off punishment and innocent people deleted

pablissimo 30 May 2007 20:19

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chef!
You are stupid for not being polite and sensible in first speaking to the MH's. For this you deserve closure.

This is probably the most stupid thing I've ever read on this forum.

xontas 30 May 2007 20:22

Re: OMG , im CHEATING
 
i just got asked to give my opinion by the tread starter and he was not happy with my responce.
i totaly agree with Ace's judgement on this.
yes, asking for a other account to assist you in un-natural gain is cheating
when i was MH (long time ago in a galaxy far far away) i would have closed him for it.

BUT!!! and listen up boys and girls, its kinda importent!

i would have reopened him after a long and hard talk about the rules.
no point in being a hardass about it when clearly the game is not affected yet.
when you have 100K players again you might want a 0 tollorance policy but now every soul is welcome (within reason ofc)

so PA i would say, open the treadstarter up again and trust that your point has been made.
he might not agree with you, but he can never again claim ignorence of the rules !! :)

-Xontas-

p.s. when did you guys stop taking this stuff to private pm's?


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:45.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2002 - 2018