Planetarion Forums
Page 2 of 2 1 2
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

Planetarion Forums (https://pirate.planetarion.com/index.php)
-   Alliance Discussions (https://pirate.planetarion.com/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater (https://pirate.planetarion.com/showthread.php?t=201478)

eksero 16 Feb 2018 16:51
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by [ND]Byrney
Is this supposed to be cheating?

Blue_Esper 16 Feb 2018 16:56
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shhhhhhh (Post 3261396)
Their ally didn't kick the accounts even after it was found out? Can't use the excuse that you didn't know if you keep closed accounts in the ally and keep using them
you can't use their fleets when they're closed idiot.

Dekker 16 Feb 2018 17:34
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261399)
you can't use their fleets when they're closed idiot.
Sh7 quoted a post which stated otherwise.

[ND]Byrney 16 Feb 2018 18:18
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by eksero (Post 3261397)
Is this supposed to be cheating?
I dunno, perhaps it's just accepted practice for ziks to farm an extra pod class early on these days. This ridiculous inc is certainly suspicious if not though.

Blue_Esper 16 Feb 2018 18:44
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dekker (Post 3261400)
Sh7 quoted a post which stated otherwise.
well they don't show on launch page for AF since they were closed so once again believing butcher facts has made a fool of you

Blue_Esper 16 Feb 2018 18:45
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by [ND]Byrney (Post 3261401)
I dunno, perhaps it's just accepted practice for ziks to farm an extra pod class early on these days. This ridiculous inc is certainly suspicious if not though.
6 4 5 is carisan who VGN has been at war with for most of the round

BloodyButcher 16 Feb 2018 20:15
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261403)
well they don't show on launch page for AF since they were closed so once again believing butcher facts has made a fool of you
Are you disputing the scans(evidence) blue_esper? Realy?
If i was you i wouldve kept a low-low profile :salute:

Ave 16 Feb 2018 20:39
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261404)
6 4 5 is carisan who VGN has been at war with for most of the round
Confirm its ours.

Spritfire 16 Feb 2018 23:50
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261403)
well they don't show on launch page for AF since they were closed so once again believing butcher facts has made a fool of you
AF fleets was sent from closed planets.
After it got pointed out to PA Team they closed the loophole, but denied to recall the fleets sent from the closed planets.

So yes VGN has been covered with cheaters fleets.

Shhhhhhh 17 Feb 2018 10:53
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261399)
you can't use their fleets when they're closed idiot.
So we're the accounts kicked?
Is there anything VGN is doing to avoid this in the future?
There seems to be quite some bad stuff happening in your ally that you don't know about.
Do you see it as a HCs responsibility to make sure ally members don't cheat?
Or is it fine as long as they don't know about it?

I'm aware cheating isn't exclusively used by VGN. Tho it's a bit disturbing to see the caught cheater is HC there. But it's really something this community needs to improve on. No matter if the cheater is in VGN or Carn or some other ally. We cant rely on MH alone to discourage and reduce the cheating.

Blue_Esper 17 Feb 2018 11:10
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shhhhhhh (Post 3261408)
So we're the accounts kicked?
Is there anything VGN is doing to avoid this in the future?
There seems to be quite some bad stuff happening in your ally that you don't know about.
Do you see it as a HCs responsibility to make sure ally members don't cheat?
Or is it fine as long as they don't know about it?

I'm aware cheating isn't exclusively used by VGN. Tho it's a bit disturbing to see the caught cheater is HC there. But it's really something this community needs to improve on. No matter if the cheater is in VGN or Carn or some other ally. We cant rely on MH alone to discourage and reduce the cheating.
Dunno why the planets need to be kicked when they cant contribute and they get deleted anyway. Its not the hc responsibility to make sure membera dont cheat thats down to planet/player. Hcs have enough on their plate.
Do you even know why the planets got closed? As i sure dont!

Caught cheater? If caught that planet would be closed its not so again speculation

BloodyButcher 17 Feb 2018 14:23
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261409)
Dunno why the planets need to be kicked when they cant contribute and they get deleted anyway. Its not the hc responsibility to make sure membera dont cheat thats down to planet/player. Hcs have enough on their plate.
Do you even know why the planets got closed? As i sure dont!

Caught cheater? If caught that planet would be closed its not so again speculation
Well apparently they were able to contribute, as you guys used their defence fleet even after they were closed.

Its the HCs responsibility to keep their alliance cheater free, if they fail to act upon cheating when they see it they are soley responsibole for the cheating continue in their tag.

I find it funny how you can miss that everytime your gal got hit basicly, 5 planets that were never in the chat rooms magicly appeared online, and came to your aid?
"i have no problem with cheaters being brought to justice. but as i haven't seen any cheating, i wouldn't have even noticed that the 8:2 planets were cheating based on the activity of VGN until people pointed it out."
How much more obvious does it have to be for you to catch something funky going on in your gal AND alliance, when EVERYONE else is aware of it?
You couldnt even figure out that the planets sent defence to your gal after they got closed, and instead try to make it out like people are making up even more "lies".

Yet you continue to try make it out like everyone is a liar, and trying to shame you for no reason.

Blue_Esper 17 Feb 2018 16:45
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BloodyButcher (Post 3261410)
Well apparently they were able to contribute, as you guys used their defence fleet even after they were closed.

Its the HCs responsibility to keep their alliance cheater free, if they fail to act upon cheating when they see it they are soley responsibole for the cheating continue in their tag.

I find it funny how you can miss that everytime your gal got hit basicly, 5 planets that were never in the chat rooms magicly appeared online, and came to your aid?
"i have no problem with cheaters being brought to justice. but as i haven't seen any cheating, i wouldn't have even noticed that the 8:2 planets were cheating based on the activity of VGN until people pointed it out."
How much more obvious does it have to be for you to catch something funky going on in your gal AND alliance, when EVERYONE else is aware of it?
You couldnt even figure out that the planets sent defence to your gal after they got closed, and instead try to make it out like people are making up even more "lies".

Yet you continue to try make it out like everyone is a liar, and trying to shame you for no reason.
pretty simple really, i joined VGN halfway through the round. there are a lot of planets that aren't in the priv chan. out of 60 planets about 40 are in priv chan, does this mean that there are 20 multi planets? i just assumed as they send def that they were active, not that they were multis, as it wouldn't be the first alliance ive joined where people who aren't in the chan are active in fleet sending aspect.

CBA 17 Feb 2018 16:46
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by BloodyButcher (Post 3261410)
Well apparently they were able to contribute, as you guys used their defence fleet even after they were closed.

Its the HCs responsibility to keep their alliance cheater free, if they fail to act upon cheating when they see it they are soley responsibole for the cheating continue in their tag.

I find it funny how you can miss that everytime your gal got hit basicly, 5 planets that were never in the chat rooms magicly appeared online, and came to your aid?
"i have no problem with cheaters being brought to justice. but as i haven't seen any cheating, i wouldn't have even noticed that the 8:2 planets were cheating based on the activity of VGN until people pointed it out."
How much more obvious does it have to be for you to catch something funky going on in your gal AND alliance, when EVERYONE else is aware of it?
You couldnt even figure out that the planets sent defence to your gal after they got closed, and instead try to make it out like people are making up even more "lies".

Yet you continue to try make it out like everyone is a liar, and trying to shame you for no reason.
You are so simple minded.


When did def planets need to be active?

If a planet is closed for suspected cheating why should the AF not be used. Until they've been closed & deleted by MH after a trial etc..

Blue_Esper 17 Feb 2018 17:03
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CBA (Post 3261412)
You are so simple minded.


When did def planets need to be active?

If a planet is closed for suspected cheating why should the AF not be used. Until they've been closed & deleted by MH after a trial etc..
guilty until proven innocent!

Ave 19 Feb 2018 20:49
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261411)
does this mean that there are 20 multi planets?
Obviously :)

Kaiba 20 Feb 2018 07:13
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CBA (Post 3261412)
You are so simple minded.


When did def planets need to be active?

If a planet is closed for suspected cheating why should the AF not be used. Until they've been closed & deleted by MH after a trial etc..
In a game where the authorities rarely take action, a closed planet is invariably an confirmation of guilt.

I would agree with your statement if 'active' planets were closed daily or weekly but they arent. These closures are almost the only ones this round of planets assigned to a competitive alliance.

As closing a planet puts it into statis and freezes its play then so should its fleet contribution to AF be frozen too. It cannot attack so why should it be able to defend?

JUDO 20 Feb 2018 21:53
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Butcher as ever you are full of shit. I had the grand total of 8 def Fleets from 8:2 in 1100 ticks. Whoa there’s abuse��.

Never let the truth get in the way of utter Bollocks tho.

Kaiba 21 Feb 2018 00:19
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by JUDO (Post 3261430)
Butcher as ever you are full of shit. I had the grand total of 8 def Fleets from 8:2 in 1100 ticks. Whoa there’s abuse��.

Never let the truth get in the way of utter Bollocks tho.
He thought you were 6:6:6. He knows its Esper now.

Blue_Esper 21 Feb 2018 05:53
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kaiba (Post 3261433)
He thought you were 6:6:6. He knows its Esper now.
6.6.6 recieved even less help from 8.2(1 fleet)! so clearly JUDO is guiilty! I'd name drop CBA but he hasn't had incs all round to utilise 8.2 def fleets!

BloodyButcher 21 Feb 2018 08:21
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by JUDO (Post 3261430)
Butcher as ever you are full of shit. I had the grand total of 8 def Fleets from 8:2 in 1100 ticks. Whoa there’s abuse��.

Never let the truth get in the way of utter Bollocks tho.
Yeah, you are quite the gentleman arnt you?
What happend to "GingerCat"?
If you have turned legit suddently, maybe you should make sure to get rid of the cheaters in your close proximity, as you are a well know multi holder from the past its easy to suspect you for being one of the brains behind it.

We both know you were aware of what was going on, and you couldve stopped this cheating a long time ago.

hylands 22 Feb 2018 12:05
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Burcher shouldnt u be closed too then you list alot of "creative solution " alliances in your profile. Your accusations are seated on a carisan crash. Boohoo if u can not win with facts then we start the namecalling game.. Sorry bows sucks ass. Btw shouldnt u report me too i had free bows salvage twice...

Jumper 17 Mar 2018 17:47
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
There are multiple repeat offenders, imo i think ppl should simply be perma banned if the are caught cheating more than once. But then Zwan and Elviz wouldnt be around, so i guess thats a loss of some sorts.. maybe i dunno :D

Ave 22 Mar 2018 08:24
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
7:9:4(VGN) is closed/being deleted, has been for 42 ticks now

So I hear.... Way to go boys :)

Seems it is gone too.

Blue_Esper 22 Mar 2018 10:25
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
don't let the truth get in the way of a good story

Ave 22 Mar 2018 11:40
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blue_Esper (Post 3261628)
don't let the truth get in the way of a good story
ofc not :)

ibenroes 23 Mar 2018 00:46
Re: "Fos" the VGN repeat cheater
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bram (Post 3260591)
Consider this case:
  • r70: a player used another planet as covop farm and received ships donations from it (unfortunately only noticed at end of r71)
  • r71: a player used another planet as covop farm and received ships donations from it (unfortunately only noticed at end of r71)
  • r72: a player used another planet as ship farm; both farm planet and actual planet got closed
  • r73: nothing special - but also not looked very closely (maybe I should do so)
  • r74: a player received a ship donation from another planet [I lack data to verify if it is/was used as covop farm]

Now guess what the action taken so far is?

Actions I would've expected:
  • closing of the repeat cheater OR as a minimum removing the ships that were donated
  • closing planet donating the ships

Actual actions taken:
  • planet donating the ships got closed (clearly a sign that something is going on)
  • planet receiving the ships remains open and gets to keep the ships

I just find this very disappointing..


For those interested: the ship donation this round:
  • ETD planet launched their first fleet after 589 ticks
  • first fleet launched was an attack fleet to a VGN planet
  • attack fleets launched consist out of: 35k Recluse (FI) and 1k Merchants (CO)
  • Fos stole 31k Recluse
  • planet being attacked had no other defence
  • planet being attacked lost zero roids

Wouldn't it be great for a Zik planet attacking with FI to have some Recluse to join on attack?
Certainly Recluse must be in great demand by Zik planets..
So let's check the universe: there are 133 Zik planets; 12 out of these have Recluse:
Amount of Recluse:
  • 174,184
  • 31,250
  • 12,700
  • 7,971
  • 7,647
  • 4,396
  • 2,330
  • 1,140
  • 1,066
  • 731
  • 710
  • 81

So by landing a single def fleet on what just happens to be the first attack fleet of a planet which just happens to launch an odd attack fleet the player became #2 in Recluses owned by Zik planets.
I guess it's all just a coincidence and nothing planned..

Note: the planet with the 174k Recluse: at this stage I can't easily find out where these came from.. (so far I can account for only 90k of them and so far I'm not convinced that it was a donation)

PS: VGN planet involved is in top 25.

PS-2: anyone interested in second hand credits? I think it's time to call quits.
No cheater in planet earth


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:39.
Page 2 of 2 1 2
Show 40 post(s) from this thread on one page

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2002 - 2018