Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Ok, stats are on Beta, are pretty close to being finished, only minor changes from now. feel free to add your opinions.
http://beta.planetarion.com/manual.pl?page=stats the basics are, each class has two races for team ups, each race has a resource stealer, these should be attacking stats. At a glance the solo's and team up attacks are as follows; "Race": "solo" "(teamup)" Fi Ter: Cath, Etd Xan: Ter, Cat, Xan (Ter, Cath, Xan, Etd) Co Zik: Cat, Etd Etd: ALL (ALL) Fr Cat: Cat, Xan, Etd Zik: Cat, Etd (Cat, Xan, Zik, Etd) De Ter: Cat, Etd Etd: Cat, Zik, Etd (Cat, Zik, Etd) Cr Cat: ALL Xan: Ter, Cat, Xan (ALL) Bs Ter: Ter, Cat, Zik, Etd Etd: Cat, Xan, Zik (ALL) Let me know your thoughts :) |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
as a side note the solo/team ups are based on if each race has good amount of that specific ship that targets that class.
for example a de team up could land on a xan planet if the xan planet doesn't have enough banshee |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
1.) I hate resource stealers. Just leads to support planets building huge resources to get stolen by a few cheaters.
2.) why do some races have 3 pods and other 2? Seems uneven. 3.) Go ahead and Mark Cath fr as unplayable. Since 2 ships, both dagger and harpy free fire on them at a lesser eta so any ally will have them. 4.) etd de same way with banshee. 1 xan 0 fleet and no land. Useless. 5.) the res stealers(if you use them) and the sk's for zik/can are worthless. Normally these are in 1 off pod classes of same level. I.e. if pods are fr they are de. Both of their res stealers and sk's are in levels they don't have pod classes on(heavy for zik, mid for xan) so they are useless. I'll look more in depth later. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
3 & 4, I think it's a case of teaming up with the other race with the same roiding fleet. Same as last round. Hard to solo once defence fleets get moving.
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
We need to remove stealing ship cus there are a few cheaters ship farming. We gotta remove astropods cus there are a few cheaters roid farming. We gotta remove cov-ops for resources/ships cus there are a few cheaters cov-op farming. We need to remove XP from the game, because people are XP farming each other. We gootta remove the ability to login to the game, because there are cheaters who logs into each other accounts to do que constructions/research or use a scan from it. :salute::salute: |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Your definition of 0 loss ships is different to mine. A 0 loss ship would be one that doesn't get targeted at all. Of which these stats have none of those.
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
OK, so I was halfway through your stats when I suddenly got incredibly bored. Not your fault, looking at stats is inherently boring.
So I wrote a program to do it for me. It checks which attack fleets can roid which races, using some very simple rules: 1) Attacker loses if there are any 0-loss defenders. EMP counts. Xan Fi cannot roid Etd because Executive is 0-loss. 2) Ter attackers beat an EMP defending ships. 3) EMP attackers lose to Ter defending ships. 4) Attacker wins if all defending ships fire after at least one attacker. Xan Cr cannot roid Zik because even though Spectre beats Thief, Pirate beats Apparition. 5) If any defender fires with same init, it must do so with a worse target class. Etd Fi can roid Etd because even though Peddler and Vendor fire at the same time, Vendor wins because it uses T1, while Peddler uses T2. It goes through them in order. If any rule applies, the rest are still checked, and the result appears in output, but they don't count any more. For example, even though Ter normally always beats EMP, 0-loss EMP beats Ter. It's not perfect, obviously, rules like this can never be completely flawless. But I think it should come pretty close. Thoughts? Running that program on your stats gives me the following output: Running simple check for Ter Fi... Ter Fi does not roid Ter: - Defender Pegasus 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Ter Fi roids Cat: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Beetle: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP Ter Fi does not roid Xan: - Defender Wraith beats attacker Phoenix: Wraith has init 5, Phoenix has init 6 - Defender Nightmare 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Ter Fi does not roid Zik: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 19 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 Ter Fi roids Etd: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Harpy beats defender Executive: Harpy has init 6, Executive has init 20 Running simple check for Ter De... Ter De does not roid Ter: - Defender Dreadnaught 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 Ter De does not roid Cat: - Attacker Pegasus beats defender Ant: Pegasus is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Drake beats defender Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Ter De does not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats attacker Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 - Defender Spectre 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Ter De does not roid Zik: - Defender Cutlass beats attacker Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 Ter De roids Etd: - Attacker Drake beats defender Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Gryphon beats defender Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Ter Bs... Ter Bs roids Ter: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 Ter Bs roids Cat: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP Ter Bs does not roid Xan: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Vsharrak: Wyvern has init 5, Vsharrak has init 6 - Defender Apparition beats attacker Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Ter Bs roids Zik: - Attacker Dragon beats defender Rogue: Dragon has init 7, Rogue has init 20 Ter Bs roids Etd: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 Running simple check for Cat Fr... Cat Fr does not roid Ter: - Defender Harpy 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships - Defender Drake beats attacker Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 Cat Fr does not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Moth: Mantis has init 1, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 Cat Fr roids Xan: - Attacker Scarab beats defender Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Cat Fr does not roid Zik: - Defender Dagger 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships - Attacker Scarab beats defender Rogue: Scarab has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Cat Fr does not roid Etd: - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 Running simple check for Cat Cr... Cat Cr does not roid Ter: - Defender Dragon beats attacker Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP Cat Cr roids Cat: - Attacker Roach beats defender Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 Cat Cr roids Xan: - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Fireblade: Tarantula has init 1, Fireblade has init 7 Cat Cr roids Zik: - Attacker Roach beats defender Thief: Roach has init 1, Thief has init 19 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Pirate: Tarantula has init 1, Pirate has init 5 Cat Cr roids Etd: - Attacker Roach beats defender Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Running simple check for Xan Fi... Xan Fi roids Ter: - Attacker Banshee beats defender Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 Xan Fi does not roid Cat: - Defender Beetle beats attacker Phantom: Beetle has init 1, Phantom has init 4 Xan Fi roids Xan: - Attacker Phantom beats defender Wraith: Phantom has init 4, Wraith has init 5 - Attacker Banshee beats defender Nightmare: Banshee has init 5, Nightmare has init 7 Xan Fi does not roid Zik: - Attacker Phantom beats defender Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 19 - Defender Buccaneer 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Xan Fi does not roid Etd: - Defender Broker beats attacker Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Defender Executive 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Running simple check for Xan Cr... Xan Cr roids Ter: - Attacker Apparition beats defender Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Xan Cr does not roid Cat: - Defender Scarab beats attacker Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Xan Cr roids Xan: - Attacker Apparition beats defender Fireblade: Apparition has init 6, Fireblade has init 7 Xan Cr does not roid Zik: - Attacker Spectre beats defender Thief: Spectre has init 5, Thief has init 19 - Defender Pirate beats attacker Apparition: Pirate has init 5, Apparition has init 6 Xan Cr does not roid Etd: - Defender Distributor beats attacker Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Running simple check for Zik Co... Zik Co does not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 19 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 Zik Co does not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Zik Co does not roid Xan: - Defender Phantom beats attacker Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 19 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Nightmare: Cutlass has init 6, Nightmare has init 7 Zik Co does not roid Zik: - Attacker Corsair beats defender Dagger: Corsair has init 19, Dagger has init 20 - Defender Clipper 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Zik Co does not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 Running simple check for Zik Fr... Zik Fr does not roid Ter: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Defender Wyvern 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Zik Fr does not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Buccaneer: Mantis has init 1, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Roach beats attacker Thief: Roach has init 1, Thief has init 19 Zik Fr does not roid Xan: - Defender Spectre beats attacker Thief: Spectre has init 5, Thief has init 19 Zik Fr roids Zik: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Dagger: Buccaneer has init 5, Dagger has init 20 - Attacker Thief beats defender Rogue: Thief has init 19, Rogue has init 20 Zik Fr does not roid Etd: - Defender Vendor beats attacker Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 20 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Retailer 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships Running simple check for Etd Co... Etd Co does not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Drake beats attacker Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP Etd Co does not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 Etd Co roids Xan: - Attacker Broker beats defender Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Nightmare: Vendor has init 2, Nightmare has init 7 Etd Co roids Zik: - Attacker Broker beats defender Dagger: Broker has init 2, Dagger has init 20 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 20 Etd Co does not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 Running simple check for Etd De... Etd De does not roid Ter: - Attacker Distributor beats defender Dreadnaught: Distributor has init 4, Dreadnaught has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 Etd De does not roid Cat: - Defender Ant 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships - Attacker Peddler beats defender Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 Etd De does not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee 0 loss defends against all attacker's ships - Attacker Distributor beats defender Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 Etd De roids Zik: - Attacker Peddler beats defender Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 Etd De roids Etd: - Attacker Peddler beats defender Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 - Attacker Investor beats defender Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Etd Bs... Etd Bs does not roid Ter: - Defender Gryphon beats attacker Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Etd Bs does not roid Cat: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Etd Bs roids Xan: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Vsharrak: Retailer has init 2, Vsharrak has init 6 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Etd Bs roids Zik: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Rogue: Retailer has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Etd Bs does not roid Etd: - Defender Investor beats attacker Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 And a little table, because I like my data organized: Code:
| | Ter | Cat | Xan | Zik | Etd | Lands on | |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
I've been meaning to do just that for a while. I kinda assumed someone had written a few basic stats analysis scripts already, since things like init and target classes are trivial to analyse.
Not sure what other rules are needed, but it's worth thinking about. Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
yeah, i guess zik as it is, is more to plug holes in def, i'll try make fr a little stronger and give it a better def ship if needed
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
also not sure that emp should be counted on def
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
zik fr is only out init by cr/bs or an emp ship
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
would make co very strong then? as it is it can already roid every race
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Update. I made 2 changes:
- teamups are now included - 0-loss EMP def no longer stops any attacker from landing. I don't like this, because that makes 0-loss EMP actually worse than standard EMP. Blue_Esper asked for it, though, so I'm using that rule here, but I'll remove it from my code. Instead, I may do proper EMP calculations. May. Still, here it is: Running simple check for Ter Fi... Ter Fi does not roid Ter: - Defender Pegasus beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter Fi roids Cat: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Beetle: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP Ter Fi does not roid Xan: - Defender Wraith beats attacker Phoenix: Wraith has init 5, Phoenix has init 6 - Defender Nightmare beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter Fi does not roid Zik: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 Ter Fi roids Etd: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Harpy beats defender Executive: Harpy has init 6, Executive has init 20 Running simple check for Ter De... Ter De does not roid Ter: - Defender Dreadnaught beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 Ter De does not roid Cat: - Attacker Pegasus beats defender Ant: Pegasus is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Drake beats defender Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Attacker ships beat defender Roach: Roach is not fired upon, but EMP does not scare off attackers - Defender Roach beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter De does not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats attacker Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 - Defender Spectre beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter De does not roid Zik: - Defender Cutlass beats attacker Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 Ter De roids Etd: - Attacker Drake beats defender Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Gryphon beats defender Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Ter Bs... Ter Bs roids Ter: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 Ter Bs roids Cat: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP Ter Bs does not roid Xan: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Vsharrak: Wyvern has init 5, Vsharrak has init 6 - Defender Apparition beats attacker Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Ter Bs roids Zik: - Attacker Dragon beats defender Rogue: Dragon has init 7, Rogue has init 20 Ter Bs roids Etd: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 Running simple check for Cat Fr... Cat Fr does not roid Ter: - Defender Harpy beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Defender Drake beats attacker Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 Cat Fr does not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Moth: Mantis has init 1, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 Cat Fr roids Xan: - Attacker Scarab beats defender Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Cat Fr does not roid Zik: - Defender Dagger beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Rogue: Scarab has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Cat Fr does not roid Etd: - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 Running simple check for Cat Cr... Cat Cr does not roid Ter: - Defender Dragon beats attacker Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP Cat Cr roids Cat: - Attacker Roach beats defender Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 Cat Cr roids Xan: - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Fireblade: Tarantula has init 1, Fireblade has init 7 Cat Cr roids Zik: - Attacker Roach beats defender Thief: Roach has init 1, Thief has init 19 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Pirate: Tarantula has init 1, Pirate has init 5 Cat Cr roids Etd: - Attacker Roach beats defender Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Running simple check for Xan Fi... Xan Fi roids Ter: - Attacker Banshee beats defender Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 Xan Fi does not roid Cat: - Defender Beetle beats attacker Phantom: Beetle has init 1, Phantom has init 4 Xan Fi roids Xan: - Attacker Phantom beats defender Wraith: Phantom has init 4, Wraith has init 5 - Attacker Banshee beats defender Nightmare: Banshee has init 5, Nightmare has init 7 Xan Fi does not roid Zik: - Attacker Phantom beats defender Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Buccaneer beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Xan Fi does not roid Etd: - Defender Broker beats attacker Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Defender Executive beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Running simple check for Xan Cr... Xan Cr roids Ter: - Attacker Apparition beats defender Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Xan Cr does not roid Cat: - Defender Scarab beats attacker Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Xan Cr roids Xan: - Attacker Apparition beats defender Fireblade: Apparition has init 6, Fireblade has init 7 Xan Cr does not roid Zik: - Attacker Spectre beats defender Thief: Spectre has init 5, Thief has init 19 - Defender Pirate beats attacker Apparition: Pirate has init 5, Apparition has init 6 Xan Cr does not roid Etd: - Defender Distributor beats attacker Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Running simple check for Zik Co... Zik Co does not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 Zik Co does not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 Zik Co does not roid Xan: - Defender Phantom beats attacker Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Nightmare: Cutlass has init 6, Nightmare has init 7 Zik Co does not roid Zik: - Attacker Corsair beats defender Dagger: Corsair has init 20, Dagger has init 21 - Defender Clipper beats attacker Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 Zik Co does not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 Running simple check for Zik Fr... Zik Fr does not roid Ter: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Zik Fr does not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Buccaneer: Mantis has init 1, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Roach beats attacker Thief: Roach has init 1, Thief has init 19 Zik Fr does not roid Xan: - Defender Spectre beats attacker Thief: Spectre has init 5, Thief has init 19 Zik Fr roids Zik: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Dagger: Buccaneer has init 5, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Clipper beats defender Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Thief beats defender Rogue: Thief has init 19, Rogue has init 20 Zik Fr does not roid Etd: - Defender Vendor beats attacker Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 - Attacker ships beat defender Retailer: Retailer is not fired upon, but EMP does not scare off attackers - Defender Retailer beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Running simple check for Etd Co... Etd Co does not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Drake beats attacker Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP Etd Co does not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 Etd Co roids Xan: - Attacker Broker beats defender Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Nightmare: Vendor has init 2, Nightmare has init 7 Etd Co roids Zik: - Attacker Broker beats defender Dagger: Broker has init 2, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 Etd Co does not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 Running simple check for Etd De... Etd De does not roid Ter: - Attacker Distributor beats defender Dreadnaught: Distributor has init 4, Dreadnaught has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 Etd De does not roid Cat: - Attacker ships beat defender Ant: Ant is not fired upon, but EMP does not scare off attackers - Defender Ant beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Attacker Peddler beats defender Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 Etd De does not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Attacker Distributor beats defender Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 Etd De roids Zik: - Attacker Peddler beats defender Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 Etd De roids Etd: - Attacker Peddler beats defender Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 - Attacker Investor beats defender Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Etd Bs... Etd Bs does not roid Ter: - Defender Gryphon beats attacker Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Etd Bs does not roid Cat: - Defender Scarab beats attacker Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Etd Bs roids Xan: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Vsharrak: Retailer has init 2, Vsharrak has init 6 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Etd Bs roids Zik: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Rogue: Retailer has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Etd Bs does not roid Etd: - Defender Investor beats attacker Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Fi teamups... Fi teamups roid Ter: - Defender Pegasus beats attacker Ant: Pegasus is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Banshee beats defender Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 Fi teamups roid Cat: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Beetle: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Beetle beats attacker Phantom: Beetle has init 1, Phantom has init 4 - Defender Beetle beats attacker Dagger: Beetle has init 1, Dagger has init 21 Fi teamups roid Xan: - Defender Wraith beats attacker Phoenix: Wraith has init 5, Phoenix has init 6 - Attacker Phantom beats defender Wraith: Phantom has init 4, Wraith has init 5 - Defender Wraith beats attacker Dagger: Wraith has init 5, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Ant beats defender Nightmare: Ant has init 3, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Banshee beats defender Nightmare: Banshee has init 5, Nightmare has init 7 Fi teamups do not roid Zik: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Phantom beats defender Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Corsair beats attacker Dagger: Corsair has init 20, Dagger has init 21 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Dagger: Buccaneer has init 5, Dagger has init 21 Fi teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Broker beats attacker Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Defender Broker beats attacker Dagger: Broker has init 2, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Harpy beats defender Executive: Harpy has init 6, Executive has init 20 - Defender Executive beats attacker Dagger: Executive has init 20, Dagger has init 21 Running simple check for Co teamups... Co teamups roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Beetle: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Wraith beats defender Phoenix: Wraith has init 5, Phoenix has init 6 - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Defender Drake beats attacker Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP Co teamups do not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 Co teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Beetle beats defender Phantom: Beetle has init 1, Phantom has init 4 - Defender Phantom beats attacker Wraith: Phantom has init 4, Wraith has init 5 - Defender Phantom beats attacker Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Broker beats defender Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Nightmare: Cutlass has init 6, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Nightmare: Vendor has init 2, Nightmare has init 7 Co teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Beetle beats defender Dagger: Beetle has init 1, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Wraith beats defender Dagger: Wraith has init 5, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Corsair beats defender Dagger: Corsair has init 20, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Broker beats defender Dagger: Broker has init 2, Dagger has init 21 - Defender Clipper beats attacker Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 Co teamups do not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 Running simple check for Fr teamups... Fr teamups do not roid Ter: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 - Defender Harpy beats attacker Executive: Harpy has init 6, Executive has init 20 - Defender Drake beats attacker Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Vsharrak: Wyvern has init 5, Vsharrak has init 6 Fr teamups do not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Moth: Mantis has init 1, Moth has init 8 - Defender Mantis beats attacker Buccaneer: Mantis has init 1, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Roach beats attacker Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 - Defender Roach beats attacker Thief: Roach has init 1, Thief has init 19 Fr teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Scarab beats defender Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 - Defender Spectre beats attacker Thief: Spectre has init 5, Thief has init 19 Fr teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Dagger: Buccaneer has init 5, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Executive beats defender Dagger: Executive has init 20, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Clipper beats defender Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Rogue: Scarab has init 2, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Thief beats defender Rogue: Thief has init 19, Rogue has init 20 Fr teamups do not roid Etd: - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 - Defender Vendor beats attacker Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Vsharrak: Retailer has init 2, Vsharrak has init 6 Running simple check for De teamups... De teamups do not roid Ter: - Attacker Distributor beats defender Dreadnaught: Distributor has init 4, Dreadnaught has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 De teamups do not roid Cat: - Attacker Pegasus beats defender Ant: Pegasus is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Ant beats attacker Nightmare: Ant has init 3, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Drake beats defender Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Mantis beats defender Moth: Mantis has init 1, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 De teamups do not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats attacker Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 - Defender Banshee beats attacker Nightmare: Banshee has init 5, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Distributor beats defender Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 De teamups roid Zik: - Defender Cutlass beats attacker Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Defender Cutlass beats attacker Nightmare: Cutlass has init 6, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Attacker Mantis beats defender Buccaneer: Mantis has init 1, Buccaneer has init 5 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 De teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Drake beats defender Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Vendor beats attacker Nightmare: Vendor has init 2, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 - Attacker Gryphon beats defender Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 - Attacker Investor beats defender Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Cr teamups... Cr teamups roid Ter: - Defender Dragon beats attacker Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Apparition beats defender Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 - Defender Dragon beats attacker Rogue: Dragon has init 7, Rogue has init 20 Cr teamups roid Cat: - Attacker Roach beats defender Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 - Defender Scarab beats attacker Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 - Defender Scarab beats attacker Rogue: Scarab has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Cr teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Fireblade: Tarantula has init 1, Fireblade has init 7 - Attacker Apparition beats defender Fireblade: Apparition has init 6, Fireblade has init 7 - Defender Fireblade beats attacker Rogue: Fireblade has init 7, Rogue has init 20 Cr teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Roach beats defender Thief: Roach has init 1, Thief has init 19 - Attacker Spectre beats defender Thief: Spectre has init 5, Thief has init 19 - Defender Thief beats attacker Rogue: Thief has init 19, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Pirate: Tarantula has init 1, Pirate has init 5 - Defender Pirate beats attacker Apparition: Pirate has init 5, Apparition has init 6 - Defender Pirate beats attacker Rogue: Pirate has init 5, Rogue has init 20 Cr teamups roid Etd: - Defender Distributor beats attacker Dreadnaught: Distributor has init 4, Dreadnaught has init 7 - Attacker Roach beats defender Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 - Defender Distributor beats attacker Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Rogue: Retailer has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Running simple check for Bs teamups... Bs teamups roid Ter: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 - Defender Gryphon beats attacker Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Bs teamups roid Cat: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Scarab beats attacker Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Fireblade: Tarantula has init 1, Fireblade has init 7 - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Pirate: Tarantula has init 1, Pirate has init 5 - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Bs teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Vsharrak: Wyvern has init 5, Vsharrak has init 6 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Vsharrak: Retailer has init 2, Vsharrak has init 6 - Defender Apparition beats attacker Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 - Defender Apparition beats attacker Fireblade: Apparition has init 6, Fireblade has init 7 - Attacker Pirate beats defender Apparition: Pirate has init 5, Apparition has init 6 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Bs teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Dragon beats defender Rogue: Dragon has init 7, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Fireblade beats defender Rogue: Fireblade has init 7, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Pirate beats defender Rogue: Pirate has init 5, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Rogue: Retailer has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Bs teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 - Defender Investor beats attacker Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Code:
| | Ter | Cat | Xan | Zik | Etd | Lands on | Code:
| | Ter | Cat | Xan | Zik | Etd | Lands on | |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
I believe this proves my point Zik have 1 good solo option for attacks. Where as almost every other fleet(not race) can roid atleast 2 others and 3+ with team-ups.
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Being bad offensively is pretty par for the course for Zik, though. That said, I would like to see 1 decent solo option for both Zik attack fleets. Beyond that, I think Ter Bs and Cat Cr could still use a nerf.
Unrelatedly, Blue_Esper pointed out a stupid inconsistency in the output I posted in my last post. Ter De can roid Cat solo (because all ships ignore 0-loss EMP in that version), but Ter/Etd De teamups cannot (because with the Distributor there, the Roach is no longer 0-loss, and it loses to the Roach). This, in my view, is confirmation that ignoring 0-loss EMP is a bad idea. Not what BE wanted to hear, I'm sure, since he was the one who asked I add it, but so it goes. :P This reveals something I was aware of all along, but may not have made explicit enough: this program is not and can never be perfect. I tried to make some reasonable assumptions that are mostly correct, but not always. Be aware of this. Use its output, by all means, but don't treat it like dogma. To get it right, I'd need to make a full bcalc and pit fleet compositions against each other. This is much more work than what I've done so far, and while I'm not saying I definitely won't do it, I'm not going to make any promises either. Additionally, this involves a new set of guesses: what are the right fleet compositions? I don't really want to input those manually either... Meanwhile, I've removed the "0-loss EMP def does not scare attackers" rule. I won't repost the entire output, but Etd De, Ter De and De teamups all now no longer roid Cat. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
i'll add some anti bs to zik fr that out inits ter bs that should plug that hole
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
so changes
Thief now targets Bs at init 4 Clipper and clipper now targets Cr at t1 and Co at t2 this shouldn't weaken the bs team up but stops one race solo'ing into zik, also makes zik the anti ter race :D |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Mz what would a good land chart look like?
2-3 lands per race pod? |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
My opinion would be 3 on average, Ter a bit less, Zik a lot less, Cat a bit more.
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
I think 2 for ter/etd/xan 3 or 4 for cath and 1 for Zik. Zik don't need to have a lot of solo attack options because they will steal into better fleets by tick 500. Also Zik trade off attacks for being one of the hardest to hit races post tick 800. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
In my view teamups are meant to stop ally/gal def, not to overcome the target planet's fleet. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
If a fleet can solo roid into 3 races then there is almost no reason for that fleet to have a team up as it will be able to roid 60% of the universe by itself. Unless all 5 races have a fleet like such it seems to me that it would be Very hard to balance. However a fleet that can roid 2 races is much more manageable. Cath being an exception and should be able to roid atleast 3 usually 4 races. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Reran my checker:
Running simple check for Ter Fi... Ter Fi does not roid Ter: - Defender Pegasus beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter Fi roids Cat: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Beetle: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP Ter Fi does not roid Xan: - Defender Wraith beats attacker Phoenix: Wraith has init 5, Phoenix has init 6 - Defender Nightmare beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter Fi does not roid Zik: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 Ter Fi roids Etd: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Harpy beats defender Executive: Harpy has init 6, Executive has init 20 Running simple check for Ter De... Ter De does not roid Ter: - Defender Dreadnaught beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 Ter De does not roid Cat: - Attacker Pegasus beats defender Ant: Pegasus is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Drake beats defender Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter De does not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats attacker Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 - Defender Spectre beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Ter De does not roid Zik: - Defender Cutlass beats attacker Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 Ter De roids Etd: - Attacker Drake beats defender Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Gryphon beats defender Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Ter Bs... Ter Bs roids Ter: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 Ter Bs roids Cat: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP Ter Bs does not roid Xan: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Vsharrak: Wyvern has init 5, Vsharrak has init 6 - Defender Apparition beats attacker Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Ter Bs does not roid Zik: - Defender Thief beats attacker Wyvern: Thief has init 4, Wyvern has init 5 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Rogue: Dragon has init 7, Rogue has init 20 Ter Bs roids Etd: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 Running simple check for Cat Fr... Cat Fr does not roid Ter: - Defender Harpy beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Defender Drake beats attacker Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 Cat Fr does not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Moth: Mantis has init 1, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 Cat Fr roids Xan: - Attacker Scarab beats defender Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Cat Fr does not roid Zik: - Defender Dagger beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Rogue: Scarab has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Cat Fr does not roid Etd: - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 Running simple check for Cat Cr... Cat Cr does not roid Ter: - Defender Dragon beats attacker Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP Cat Cr roids Cat: - Attacker Roach beats defender Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 Cat Cr roids Xan: - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Fireblade: Tarantula has init 1, Fireblade has init 7 Cat Cr roids Zik: - Attacker Roach beats defender Clipper: Roach has init 1, Clipper has init 19 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Pirate: Tarantula has init 1, Pirate has init 5 Cat Cr roids Etd: - Attacker Roach beats defender Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Running simple check for Xan Fi... Xan Fi roids Ter: - Attacker Banshee beats defender Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 Xan Fi does not roid Cat: - Defender Beetle beats attacker Phantom: Beetle has init 1, Phantom has init 4 Xan Fi roids Xan: - Attacker Phantom beats defender Wraith: Phantom has init 4, Wraith has init 5 - Attacker Banshee beats defender Nightmare: Banshee has init 5, Nightmare has init 7 Xan Fi does not roid Zik: - Attacker Phantom beats defender Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Buccaneer beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Xan Fi does not roid Etd: - Defender Broker beats attacker Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Defender Executive beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence Running simple check for Xan Cr... Xan Cr roids Ter: - Attacker Apparition beats defender Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Xan Cr does not roid Cat: - Defender Scarab beats attacker Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Xan Cr roids Xan: - Attacker Apparition beats defender Fireblade: Apparition has init 6, Fireblade has init 7 Xan Cr does not roid Zik: - Attacker Spectre beats defender Clipper: Spectre has init 5, Clipper has init 19 - Defender Pirate beats attacker Apparition: Pirate has init 5, Apparition has init 6 Xan Cr does not roid Etd: - Defender Distributor beats attacker Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Running simple check for Zik Co... Zik Co does not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 Zik Co does not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 Zik Co does not roid Xan: - Defender Phantom beats attacker Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Nightmare: Cutlass has init 6, Nightmare has init 7 Zik Co does not roid Zik: - Attacker Corsair beats defender Dagger: Corsair has init 20, Dagger has init 21 - Defender Clipper beats attacker Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 Zik Co does not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 Running simple check for Zik Fr... Zik Fr roids Ter: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Attacker Thief beats defender Wyvern: Thief has init 4, Wyvern has init 5 Zik Fr does not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Buccaneer: Mantis has init 1, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Roach beats attacker Clipper: Roach has init 1, Clipper has init 19 Zik Fr does not roid Xan: - Defender Spectre beats attacker Clipper: Spectre has init 5, Clipper has init 19 Zik Fr roids Zik: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Dagger: Buccaneer has init 5, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Clipper beats defender Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Clipper beats defender Rogue: Clipper has init 19, Rogue has init 20 Zik Fr does not roid Etd: - Defender Vendor beats attacker Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Thief: Retailer has init 2, Thief has init 4 Running simple check for Etd Co... Etd Co does not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Drake beats attacker Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP Etd Co does not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 Etd Co roids Xan: - Attacker Broker beats defender Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Nightmare: Vendor has init 2, Nightmare has init 7 Etd Co roids Zik: - Attacker Broker beats defender Dagger: Broker has init 2, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 Etd Co does not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 Running simple check for Etd De... Etd De does not roid Ter: - Attacker Distributor beats defender Dreadnaught: Distributor has init 4, Dreadnaught has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 Etd De does not roid Cat: - Defender Ant beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Attacker Peddler beats defender Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 Etd De does not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats all attacker ships: 0 loss defence - Attacker Distributor beats defender Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 Etd De roids Zik: - Attacker Peddler beats defender Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 Etd De roids Etd: - Attacker Peddler beats defender Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 - Attacker Investor beats defender Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Etd Bs... Etd Bs does not roid Ter: - Defender Gryphon beats attacker Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Etd Bs does not roid Cat: - Defender Scarab beats attacker Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Etd Bs roids Xan: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Vsharrak: Retailer has init 2, Vsharrak has init 6 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Etd Bs roids Zik: - Attacker Retailer beats defender Thief: Retailer has init 2, Thief has init 4 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Rogue: Retailer has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Etd Bs does not roid Etd: - Defender Investor beats attacker Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Fi teamups... Fi teamups roid Ter: - Attacker Banshee beats defender Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 Fi teamups roid Cat: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Beetle: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Beetle beats attacker Phantom: Beetle has init 1, Phantom has init 4 Fi teamups roid Xan: - Defender Wraith beats attacker Phoenix: Wraith has init 5, Phoenix has init 6 - Attacker Phantom beats defender Wraith: Phantom has init 4, Wraith has init 5 - Attacker Banshee beats defender Nightmare: Banshee has init 5, Nightmare has init 7 Fi teamups do not roid Zik: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Phantom beats defender Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 Fi teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Phoenix beats defender Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Broker beats attacker Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Attacker Harpy beats defender Executive: Harpy has init 6, Executive has init 20 Running simple check for Co teamups... Co teamups do not roid Ter: - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Corsair: Phoenix has init 6, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Phoenix beats attacker Broker: Phoenix is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Defender Drake beats attacker Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP Co teamups do not roid Cat: - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 - Defender Black Widow beats attacker Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 Co teamups roid Xan: - Defender Phantom beats attacker Corsair: Phantom has init 4, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Broker beats defender Phantom: Broker has init 2, Phantom has init 4 - Attacker Cutlass beats defender Nightmare: Cutlass has init 6, Nightmare has init 7 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Nightmare: Vendor has init 2, Nightmare has init 7 Co teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Corsair beats defender Dagger: Corsair has init 20, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Broker beats defender Dagger: Broker has init 2, Dagger has init 21 - Defender Clipper beats attacker Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Vendor beats defender Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 Co teamups do not roid Etd: - Defender Peddler beats attacker Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 Running simple check for Fr teamups... Fr teamups roid Ter: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Harpy: Buccaneer has init 5, Harpy has init 6 - Defender Drake beats attacker Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Thief beats defender Wyvern: Thief has init 4, Wyvern has init 5 Fr teamups do not roid Cat: - Defender Mantis beats attacker Moth: Mantis has init 1, Moth has init 8 - Defender Mantis beats attacker Buccaneer: Mantis has init 1, Buccaneer has init 5 - Defender Roach beats attacker Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 - Defender Roach beats attacker Clipper: Roach has init 1, Clipper has init 19 Fr teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Scarab beats defender Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 - Defender Spectre beats attacker Clipper: Spectre has init 5, Clipper has init 19 Fr teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Buccaneer beats defender Dagger: Buccaneer has init 5, Dagger has init 21 - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Corsair: Black Widow has init 1, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Clipper beats defender Corsair: Clipper has init 19, Corsair has init 20 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Rogue: Scarab has init 2, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Clipper beats defender Rogue: Clipper has init 19, Rogue has init 20 Fr teamups do not roid Etd: - Attacker Black Widow beats defender Vendor: Black Widow has init 1, Vendor has init 2 - Defender Vendor beats attacker Clipper: Vendor has init 2, Clipper has init 19 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Peddler beats attacker Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 - Attacker Scarab beats defender Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Thief: Retailer has init 2, Thief has init 4 Running simple check for De teamups... De teamups do not roid Ter: - Attacker Distributor beats defender Dreadnaught: Distributor has init 4, Dreadnaught has init 7 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 - Defender Wyvern beats attacker Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 De teamups do not roid Cat: - Attacker Pegasus beats defender Ant: Pegasus is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Drake beats defender Moth: Drake has init 7, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Moth: Peddler has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Defender Roach beats attacker Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 De teamups do not roid Xan: - Defender Banshee beats attacker Pegasus: Banshee has init 5, Pegasus has init 6 - Attacker Distributor beats defender Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 De teamups roid Zik: - Defender Cutlass beats attacker Drake: Cutlass has init 6, Drake has init 7 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Cutlass: Peddler has init 2, Cutlass has init 6 - Defender Buccaneer beats attacker Drake: Buccaneer has init 5, Drake has init 7 - Attacker Peddler beats defender Buccaneer: Peddler has init 2, Buccaneer has init 5 De teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Drake beats defender Vendor: Drake is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Peddler beats defender Vendor: Both sides fire at init 2, but Peddler uses t1, while Vendor uses t2 - Attacker Gryphon beats defender Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 - Attacker Investor beats defender Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Running simple check for Cr teamups... Cr teamups roid Ter: - Defender Dragon beats attacker Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP - Attacker Apparition beats defender Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 Cr teamups roid Cat: - Attacker Roach beats defender Scarab: Roach has init 1, Scarab has init 2 - Defender Scarab beats attacker Spectre: Scarab has init 2, Spectre has init 5 Cr teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Fireblade: Tarantula has init 1, Fireblade has init 7 - Attacker Apparition beats defender Fireblade: Apparition has init 6, Fireblade has init 7 Cr teamups roid Zik: - Attacker Roach beats defender Clipper: Roach has init 1, Clipper has init 19 - Attacker Spectre beats defender Clipper: Spectre has init 5, Clipper has init 19 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Pirate: Tarantula has init 1, Pirate has init 5 - Defender Pirate beats attacker Apparition: Pirate has init 5, Apparition has init 6 Cr teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Roach beats defender Distributor: Roach has init 1, Distributor has init 4 - Defender Distributor beats attacker Spectre: Distributor has init 4, Spectre has init 5 - Attacker Tarantula beats defender Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 - Defender Retailer beats attacker Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Running simple check for Bs teamups... Bs teamups roid Ter: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Gryphon: Wyvern has init 5, Gryphon has init 8 - Defender Gryphon beats attacker Tycoon: Gryphon has init 8, Tycoon has init 20 Bs teamups roid Cat: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Scarab: Wyvern is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Scarab beats attacker Retailer: Both sides fire at init 2, but Scarab uses t1, while Retailer uses t2 - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Moth: Wyvern has init 5, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Moth: Retailer has init 2, Moth has init 8 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Tarantula: Dragon is Ter and resists EMP - Defender Tarantula beats attacker Retailer: Tarantula has init 1, Retailer has init 2 Bs teamups roid Xan: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Vsharrak: Wyvern has init 5, Vsharrak has init 6 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Vsharrak: Retailer has init 2, Vsharrak has init 6 - Defender Apparition beats attacker Dragon: Apparition has init 6, Dragon has init 7 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Apparition: Retailer has init 2, Apparition has init 6 Bs teamups roid Zik: - Defender Thief beats attacker Wyvern: Thief has init 4, Wyvern has init 5 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Thief: Retailer has init 2, Thief has init 4 - Attacker Dragon beats defender Rogue: Dragon has init 7, Rogue has init 20 - Attacker Retailer beats defender Rogue: Retailer has init 2, Rogue has init 20 Bs teamups roid Etd: - Attacker Wyvern beats defender Investor: Wyvern has init 5, Investor has init 7 - Defender Investor beats attacker Tycoon: Investor has init 7, Tycoon has init 20 Code:
| | Ter | Cat | Xan | Zik | Etd | Roids | Code:
| | Ter | Cat | Xan | Zik | Etd | Roids | - De: even the teamup only roids 2 races, and there's little point for Etd De to team up, because De teamups land on the same races as Etd De does solo. - Cat Cr: looks strong defensively as well as offensively, compared to say, Etd, which is as strong defensively, but much weaker offensively. - Xan: a lot of fleets roid it, while its attack fleets can't land that much. A more detailed analysis would be required to look for minor issues, but if you can fix those 3 issues, I'd say we'd have a decent candidate for r63. Allowing De to roid Cat and Xan to be invulnerable to Cr would be a big step forward. First 2 options that come to mind are: Fireblade: Class Bs -> Cr Moth: T2 De -> -- Black Widow: T2 -- -> De And: Tula: Type EMP -> Norm, Init 1 -> 8, Moth: Type Norm -> EMP, Init 8 -> 2, Mantis: Init 1 -> 2 |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
cath&etd cant def against Co with ally eta // ter cant def against Fi&De with ally eta // xan cant def agaist Fr with ally eta
why this? |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
There are reason for why you would want to have off eta and off class def ships. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
umm what?
both xan attack fleets solo 3 races? how are they weak offensively? cat is emp so your calculator machine makes it look amazing the only thing i agree with is that de is weak offensively, i don't want to add a new targetting assignment to either race otherwise de will become to strong as they will have a 4 ship build effectively. De is not the super roiding fleet but i believe it makes it up by being defensively superior. just playing on bcalcs to see what i can do to boost de without reducing an attack fleet |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
added another ship to ter that targets Co eta init 5 which gives ter another roiding option, thoughts?
the other option is to change banshee to target fr and remove de targetting of fi |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Stats that promote forts suck.
Its bad enough dealing with alliance emo in general but forts means you are pretty much always hitting someone "too much" |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
Quote:
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
i believe he means making stats with so many races not being able to make ally def against some classes, makes a round pro fortress. even more from what they already are.
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
I haven't seen a stat set not do that for a number of rounds.
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
last rounds set had ally eta ships?
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
You need to fix res stealer costs.
Alternatively, remove them. Also, it's impossible to balance Fi res stealers if each point of damage steals 50 resources. Should be 5, or maybe even 1. |
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
All res stealers are the same they're as balanced as balanced can be
|
Re: Blue's Stat Set Rnd 63
A fi that costs 6k resources and has 97 ERes is not balanced.
|
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 01:12. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2002 - 2018